IT’S NOT ALL GREEK TO EUROPE – or the Politics of Everyone

Standard

“What we have at the moment in Europe are two political currents colliding and clashing … On the one hand, you have the traditional powers that be – the bankers, big business, the traditional political parties imposing their will from above – and on the other, you’ve got grass roots movements, people-driven, saying no to the status quo and with an alternative vision of society like we see in Spain, Italy and France.”

So said Katya Adler on the Today programme this week, talking about the Greek debt crisis and the upcoming referendum on the Greek bail-out package.

It resonated with the concept of everyone that I’ve written about before (see the entry in October 2014) – the idea that everyone’s view is equally valid and that everyone is entitled to have their say.

The comments in Katya Adler’s piece supported a wider case that disaffection with the EU is now infecting the whole of Europe. Whether that’s in the form of anti-EU backlash in the UK, protesters on the streets in Spain or other unease elsewhere, a common theme can be detected.

But I’m also sensing a wider issue: that the popular view of everyone (or, at least, anyone who voices an opinion) is potentially more valid than the view of traditional – and traditionally-elected – governments. It’s further fundamental questioning of the establishment.

I’m not clear whether this is a temporary trend or part of a longer-term and potentially seismic shift in political behaviour. It also appears to be more pronounced in some countries – Greece, Spain and Italy spring to mind – than in others.

There might, though, be a correlation between the level of austerity imposed by a government and the perceived authority of the popular response. In other words, the greater the sacrifices the government asks people to make, the more likely people are to consider that they therefore have a right to express their opinion, for that opinion to be recognised as valid and for their opinion to be taken into account.

If a government were to take account of the voice of the people and alter its stance, that austerity or other area of dispute would ease and the popular voice should then subside. If the government continues to think that it knows best and runs counter to the popular voice, tensions can build, resulting in the colliding and clashing referred to by Katya Adler.

So, should there be strong government, one which always knows best? Or should the government be the organ of the people, doing what the people have told it to do, even where that message is given on the street, rather than in the polling booths?

Would that be a pure and distilled example of democracy, a version of communism or a temporary aberration? I don’t know – and I also don’t know how this particular story ends.

2 thoughts on “IT’S NOT ALL GREEK TO EUROPE – or the Politics of Everyone

  1. mrtrench

    My opinion of the Greek situation has changed recently following a two week holiday on Crete (just got back a couple of days ago). They keep pointing out that they let the Germans off their WWII debts – and I hadn’t appreciated how soundly the Germans trashed Greece at that time. Being a poor country anyway, I suspect that they have never really been able to recover from that time (they killed a large proportion of the population – proportionally greater than any other European country… surprising isn’t it?)

    However, generally I am firmly anti-EMU on economic grounds. How can a single currency, a single interest rate, possibly work across the polar economies of both Germany and Greece? As the Germans hold the power in this union, it’s never going to work for Greece, Portugal, Eire et al. They need to bite the bullet, make a sharp Grexit and take the pain for a few years for a healthier future IMO.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s